Ace Attorney Investigations Collection Review: Edgeworth’s Greatest Cases Return

The streets of justice are calling once again as Miles Edgeworth steps back into the spotlight in The Great Ace Attorney Investigations 1 & 2: The Edgeworth Collection. These Nintendo DS gems from 2009 and 2011 have been polished up for modern platforms, bringing sharper visuals and smart quality-of-life features to the table.

While you won’t find yourself shouting “Objection!” across a courtroom this time around, what you get instead is just as engaging – a chance to walk in the shoes of everyone’s favorite prosecutor as he meticulously pieces together evidence at crime scenes. The collection brings together two games that broke new ground in the series by shifting focus from courtroom theatrics to hands-on detective work, all while maintaining the sharp wit and clever writing the franchise is known for.

Story and Characters

If you’ve ever wanted to know what makes Miles Edgeworth tick, this collection delivers in spades. Beyond the stern exterior and perfectly maintained cravat lies a complex character whose development unfolds through each carefully crafted case. The stories dig deep into Edgeworth’s journey to becoming the prosecutor we know today, with familiar faces like the ever-loyal Detective Gumshoe and the sharp-tongued Franziska von Karma playing key roles along the way. What sets these games apart isn’t just the mystery-solving – it’s how they tackle weighty themes of justice and morality. Edgeworth often finds himself wrestling with ethical dilemmas that go beyond simple right and wrong, making each case feel personally meaningful rather than just another puzzle to solve.

The narrative strength lies in how it peels back layers of Edgeworth’s character that the main series rarely explores. Through his interactions with both allies and opponents, we see a more human side to the usually stoic prosecutor. Each case builds upon the last, creating a rich tapestry of interconnected stories that reveal not just who Edgeworth is, but why he became the person he is. The emotional bonds formed throughout the investigations add depth to every interaction, while the moral challenges he faces force players to think beyond simple guilt and innocence. Whether he’s bantering with Gumshoe or matching wits with cunning suspects, these games showcase Edgeworth at his most compelling.

Gameplay Mechanics

Trading the courtroom for crime scenes might seem like a bold move for an Ace Attorney title, but it works surprisingly well. Instead of cross-examining witnesses from behind a bench, you’ll find yourself in the thick of the action, engaging in heated “Rebuttal Debates” right where the crimes took place. The collection introduces some clever new tools to keep things interesting. The “Mind Chess” system turns conversations into strategic battles, where reading body language and carefully choosing responses can make or break your case. Meanwhile, the “Little Thief” system lets you recreate crime scenes in detail, adding a high-tech twist to your investigation toolkit.

The gameplay loop feels fresh while maintaining familiar elements that fans love. You’ll still need to spot contradictions and present evidence, but now you’re doing it while actively investigating crime scenes. The “Mind Chess” system adds an extra layer of strategy – watching suspects squirm under pressure or seeing their confidence crack when you corner them with logic is just as satisfying as any courtroom victory. The “Little Thief” system isn’t just a fancy way to look at crime scenes; it becomes an essential tool for understanding complex cases, letting you test theories and spot details you might have missed.

Even without courtroom dramatics, the tension remains high. Each confrontation with a suspect feels like a mental chess match, where careful observation and timing are crucial. The game keeps you on your toes by varying the pace – sometimes you’re methodically gathering evidence, other times you’re in intense face-offs where one wrong move could derail your entire investigation. This variety helps maintain engagement throughout both games, ensuring the investigation-focused gameplay never feels repetitive.

Enhanced Features

The remaster doesn’t just stop at prettier graphics – it brings some genuinely useful features to the table. Want to replay your favorite case without slogging through the whole game? The Chapter Select feature has you covered. More interested in the story than the puzzle-solving? Story Mode lets you kick back and enjoy the narrative without getting stuck on the tougher challenges. And for those who like to keep track of every detail, the Dialogue Log ensures you won’t miss any important plot points. These aren’t just fancy add-ons – they’re thoughtful improvements that make the games more accessible and enjoyable for different types of players.

The modernization goes beyond simple convenience features. The Chapter Select option recognizes that players might want to revisit particular cases that resonated with them or show friends specific moments without the commitment of a full playthrough. Story Mode isn’t just about skipping puzzles – it transforms the experience into an interactive drama, perfect for those who want to focus on the narrative without the pressure of getting stuck. The Dialogue Log proves invaluable for keeping track of complex cases, letting you review previous conversations to catch subtle hints or foreshadowing you might have missed the first time around.

These quality-of-life improvements show a deep understanding of how different players approach these games. Veterans can jump straight to challenging cases or replay favorite moments, while newcomers can ease into the experience without feeling overwhelmed. The ability to toggle these features on and off means players can customize their experience to match their preferred play style, making this collection more accessible than ever while maintaining the core challenge for those who want it.

Visual and Audio Presentation

When it comes to looks, the Ace Attorney Investigations Collection gives you the best of both worlds. The new HD graphics bring Edgeworth and company to life with smooth animations and expressive character models that capture every confident smirk and thoughtful frown. But if you’re feeling nostalgic, you can switch back to the original pixel art style at any time.

The visual upgrade goes beyond simple resolution improvements. Character animations are more fluid, with subtle gestures and expressions adding new layers to each interaction. Edgeworth’s infamous cravat flutter and confident pointing feel more dynamic than ever, while supporting characters benefit from enhanced expressiveness that makes emotional moments hit harder. Environmental details pop in HD, making crime scene investigation more engaging as you spot crucial evidence among the enhanced visuals.

The art gallery is a treasure trove for fans, packed with character designs, development sketches, and other behind-the-scenes material that unlocks as you progress. These extras provide fascinating insights into the creative process, showing how characters evolved from concept to final design. The ability to switch between visual styles isn’t just a novelty – it’s a wonderful way to appreciate both the original artwork and how the remaster enhances it while maintaining the series’ distinctive style.

The audio presentation deserves special mention, as the soundtrack masterfully sets the tone for each situation. From tension-filled investigation themes to triumphant breakthrough moments, the music enhances every scene without overwhelming it. The option to switch between remastered and original soundtracks lets players choose their preferred audio experience, whether they’re after crystal-clear modern sound or the nostalgic bite of the original tracks.

Verdict

The Ace Attorney Investigations Collection proves that you don’t need a courtroom to create compelling legal drama. While some fans might miss pointing fingers and shouting objections, the solid investigation mechanics and deeper dive into Edgeworth’s character more than make up for it. The remaster thoughtfully modernizes these games without losing their original charm, making them accessible to newcomers while giving veterans plenty of reasons to return to the scene of the crime.

The gameplay might feel different from traditional Ace Attorney titles, but the heart of what makes these games special – clever writing, engaging mysteries, and satisfying “aha!” moments – remains firmly intact. With its mix of enhanced features and preserved classic elements, this collection shows how to update beloved games for modern audiences while respecting what made them great in the first place.

Whether you’re a longtime fan or just curious about what makes Miles Edgeworth such a compelling character, the Ace Attorney Investigations Collection offers a detective experience that’s worth taking the stand for. The combination of thoughtful gameplay mechanics, strong character development, and modern conveniences creates a package that succeeds both as a nostalgia piece and as a fresh take on the investigation genre. These games might have you trading the judge’s gavel for a magnifying glass, but the thrill of pursuit and the satisfaction of solving a complex case remain just as potent as ever.

Ace Attorney Investigations Collection

Publisher: Capcom

Developer: Capcom

Release Date: 2024-09-06

Microsoft Windows, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Steam, Xbox One

Miles Edgeworth's dramatic turnabouts take center stage! Experience both Ace Attorney Investigations games in one gorgeous collection! Investigate crime scenes and solve tough, intriguing cases through logic and deduction. When Edgeworth's past and present collide, his future begins!

Join Us!

Featured Video