GamerBraves
  • News
    • All
    • 3DS
    • All
    • Android
    • Anime
    • AR
    • Battle Royale
    • Beta
    • BlackBerry
    • Closed Beta
    • Comic Book
    • Concert
    • Console
    • Cookbook
    • Demo
    • Desktops
    • DLC
    • Dota 2
    • Early Access
    • Epic Games Store
    • esports
    • Event
    • Exclusive
    • Expasion
    • Feature
    • Film
    • First Impressions
    • Gadgets
    • Gaming Laptop
    • Giveaway
    • Guides
    • Industry
    • Interview
    • iOS
    • Laptops
    • Launched
    • Linux
    • Mac
    • Malaysia
    • Manga
    • Merchandise
    • Mobile Games
    • Mobile Phone
    • Movie
    • Music
    • New Games
    • News
    • Newsletter
    • Nintendo Switch
    • Nintendo Switch (Platform)
    • NSFW
    • Open Beta
    • Opinion
    • Origin
    • PC
    • pin to top
    • PlayStation VR
    • Podcast
    • Pre-registration
    • Preview
    • PS4
    • PS4 (Platform)
    • PS5
    • PS5 (Platform)
    • PSVita
    • Reviews
    • Rumour
    • Shut down
    • Soft Launch
    • Sponsored
    • Stadia
    • Steam
    • Streaming Series
    • System Update
    • Tablet
    • Tabletop Gaming
    • Tech
    • Television
    • Theme
    • Tournament
    • Unboxing
    • Uncategorized
    • Update
    • VR
    • VTuber
    • Windows
    • Windows Phone
    • Xbox One
    • XBox One (Platform)
    • Xbox Series X
    • XBox Series X (Platform)
    Wuthering Waves Closed beta Registration

    Wuthering Waves Closed Beta Registration Tomorrow

    honor magic 5 pro

    Honor Magic 5 Pro Review – A Powerful Phone Made For Gamers and Content Creators

    Scars Above Review – Sci-Fi Shooter Meets Souslike

    Scars Above Review – Sci-Fi Shooter Meets Souslike

    Atelier Ryza series anime adaptation

    Atelier Ryza Anime Adaptation Announced

    Hololive English To Have First Concert in LA

    Hololive English To Have First Concert in LA

    NVIDIA GeForce NOW Exclusive Beta Powered by Yes launched

    Yes 5G announces NVIDIA GeForce NOW Exclusive Beta for Malaysia Launched

    persona wada

    Persona Producer Kazuhisa Wada Talks About The Challenges Of Porting The Series To Modern Platforms

    SEGA Steam Spring Sale Announcement

    SEGA Steam Spring Sale offering up to 85% off

    Hunt The Night Release

    Hunt The Night Release Date Announced For PC Following Delay

  • Reviews
    • All
    • 3DS
    • All
    • Android
    • Anime
    • AR
    • Battle Royale
    • Beta
    • BlackBerry
    • Closed Beta
    • Comic Book
    • Concert
    • Console
    • Cookbook
    • Demo
    • Desktops
    • DLC
    • Dota 2
    • Early Access
    • Epic Games Store
    • esports
    • Event
    • Exclusive
    • Expasion
    • Feature
    • Film
    • First Impressions
    • Gadgets
    • Gaming Laptop
    • Giveaway
    • Guides
    • Industry
    • Interview
    • iOS
    • Laptops
    • Launched
    • Linux
    • Mac
    • Malaysia
    • Manga
    • Merchandise
    • Mobile Games
    • Mobile Phone
    • Movie
    • Music
    • New Games
    • News
    • Newsletter
    • Nintendo Switch
    • Nintendo Switch (Platform)
    • NSFW
    • Open Beta
    • Opinion
    • Origin
    • PC
    • pin to top
    • PlayStation VR
    • Podcast
    • Pre-registration
    • Preview
    • PS4
    • PS4 (Platform)
    • PS5
    • PS5 (Platform)
    • PSVita
    • Reviews
    • Rumour
    • Shut down
    • Soft Launch
    • Sponsored
    • Stadia
    • Steam
    • Streaming Series
    • System Update
    • Tablet
    • Tabletop Gaming
    • Tech
    • Television
    • Theme
    • Tournament
    • Unboxing
    • Uncategorized
    • Update
    • VR
    • VTuber
    • Windows
    • Windows Phone
    • Xbox One
    • XBox One (Platform)
    • Xbox Series X
    • XBox Series X (Platform)
    Wuthering Waves Closed beta Registration

    Wuthering Waves Closed Beta Registration Tomorrow

    honor magic 5 pro

    Honor Magic 5 Pro Review – A Powerful Phone Made For Gamers and Content Creators

    Scars Above Review – Sci-Fi Shooter Meets Souslike

    Scars Above Review – Sci-Fi Shooter Meets Souslike

    Atelier Ryza series anime adaptation

    Atelier Ryza Anime Adaptation Announced

    Hololive English To Have First Concert in LA

    Hololive English To Have First Concert in LA

    NVIDIA GeForce NOW Exclusive Beta Powered by Yes launched

    Yes 5G announces NVIDIA GeForce NOW Exclusive Beta for Malaysia Launched

    persona wada

    Persona Producer Kazuhisa Wada Talks About The Challenges Of Porting The Series To Modern Platforms

    SEGA Steam Spring Sale Announcement

    SEGA Steam Spring Sale offering up to 85% off

    Hunt The Night Release

    Hunt The Night Release Date Announced For PC Following Delay

  • Interviews
    resident evil knife

    Resident Evil 4 (2023) Interview: The New Knife Parry Was Made Specifically For The Krauser Fight

    World of Warcraft Embers of Neltharion

    Maria Hamilton And Patrick Dawson Promise Incredibly Slow Snail Mounts In Embers Of Neltharion

    Warwick PlayStation Malaysia

    Warwick Light Talks Getting More PlayStation 5 Units To Malaysians, Spider-Man In Bukit Bintang and His Love For Nasi Lemak

    final fantasy xvi ifrit

    Final Fantasy XVI Naoki Yoshida Interview: Ifrit Is The Main Eikon Because We Felt Sorry For Him

    Masahiro Inoue Interview – Getting to Know The Face of Kamen Rider Decade

    Masahiro Inoue Interview – Getting to Know The Face of Kamen Rider Decade

    Octopath Traveler interview

    Octopath Traveler II Interview: Producer Talks On Character Interaction and Further Evolving The HD-2D Art Style

    horizon interview

    Horizon Call Of The Mountain Interview: Narrative Director Ben McCaw On Adapting Horizon To VR

    Theatrhythm Interview

    Theatrhythm Final Bar Line Producer and Director Discuss Choosing Tracks From Each FF Game In New Interview

    WIld Hearts Interview

    Wild Hearts Directors Say They Want The Game To Be The Start of A “Saga”

    Trending Tags

    • CareerBraves
    • Media Partners
      • Wanuxi
      • Gamer Santai
      • GamerWK
    No Result
    View All Result
    • News
      • All
      • 3DS
      • All
      • Android
      • Anime
      • AR
      • Battle Royale
      • Beta
      • BlackBerry
      • Closed Beta
      • Comic Book
      • Concert
      • Console
      • Cookbook
      • Demo
      • Desktops
      • DLC
      • Dota 2
      • Early Access
      • Epic Games Store
      • esports
      • Event
      • Exclusive
      • Expasion
      • Feature
      • Film
      • First Impressions
      • Gadgets
      • Gaming Laptop
      • Giveaway
      • Guides
      • Industry
      • Interview
      • iOS
      • Laptops
      • Launched
      • Linux
      • Mac
      • Malaysia
      • Manga
      • Merchandise
      • Mobile Games
      • Mobile Phone
      • Movie
      • Music
      • New Games
      • News
      • Newsletter
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Nintendo Switch (Platform)
      • NSFW
      • Open Beta
      • Opinion
      • Origin
      • PC
      • pin to top
      • PlayStation VR
      • Podcast
      • Pre-registration
      • Preview
      • PS4
      • PS4 (Platform)
      • PS5
      • PS5 (Platform)
      • PSVita
      • Reviews
      • Rumour
      • Shut down
      • Soft Launch
      • Sponsored
      • Stadia
      • Steam
      • Streaming Series
      • System Update
      • Tablet
      • Tabletop Gaming
      • Tech
      • Television
      • Theme
      • Tournament
      • Unboxing
      • Uncategorized
      • Update
      • VR
      • VTuber
      • Windows
      • Windows Phone
      • Xbox One
      • XBox One (Platform)
      • Xbox Series X
      • XBox Series X (Platform)
      Wuthering Waves Closed beta Registration

      Wuthering Waves Closed Beta Registration Tomorrow

      honor magic 5 pro

      Honor Magic 5 Pro Review – A Powerful Phone Made For Gamers and Content Creators

      Scars Above Review – Sci-Fi Shooter Meets Souslike

      Scars Above Review – Sci-Fi Shooter Meets Souslike

      Atelier Ryza series anime adaptation

      Atelier Ryza Anime Adaptation Announced

      Hololive English To Have First Concert in LA

      Hololive English To Have First Concert in LA

      NVIDIA GeForce NOW Exclusive Beta Powered by Yes launched

      Yes 5G announces NVIDIA GeForce NOW Exclusive Beta for Malaysia Launched

      persona wada

      Persona Producer Kazuhisa Wada Talks About The Challenges Of Porting The Series To Modern Platforms

      SEGA Steam Spring Sale Announcement

      SEGA Steam Spring Sale offering up to 85% off

      Hunt The Night Release

      Hunt The Night Release Date Announced For PC Following Delay

    • Reviews
      • All
      • 3DS
      • All
      • Android
      • Anime
      • AR
      • Battle Royale
      • Beta
      • BlackBerry
      • Closed Beta
      • Comic Book
      • Concert
      • Console
      • Cookbook
      • Demo
      • Desktops
      • DLC
      • Dota 2
      • Early Access
      • Epic Games Store
      • esports
      • Event
      • Exclusive
      • Expasion
      • Feature
      • Film
      • First Impressions
      • Gadgets
      • Gaming Laptop
      • Giveaway
      • Guides
      • Industry
      • Interview
      • iOS
      • Laptops
      • Launched
      • Linux
      • Mac
      • Malaysia
      • Manga
      • Merchandise
      • Mobile Games
      • Mobile Phone
      • Movie
      • Music
      • New Games
      • News
      • Newsletter
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Nintendo Switch (Platform)
      • NSFW
      • Open Beta
      • Opinion
      • Origin
      • PC
      • pin to top
      • PlayStation VR
      • Podcast
      • Pre-registration
      • Preview
      • PS4
      • PS4 (Platform)
      • PS5
      • PS5 (Platform)
      • PSVita
      • Reviews
      • Rumour
      • Shut down
      • Soft Launch
      • Sponsored
      • Stadia
      • Steam
      • Streaming Series
      • System Update
      • Tablet
      • Tabletop Gaming
      • Tech
      • Television
      • Theme
      • Tournament
      • Unboxing
      • Uncategorized
      • Update
      • VR
      • VTuber
      • Windows
      • Windows Phone
      • Xbox One
      • XBox One (Platform)
      • Xbox Series X
      • XBox Series X (Platform)
      Wuthering Waves Closed beta Registration

      Wuthering Waves Closed Beta Registration Tomorrow

      honor magic 5 pro

      Honor Magic 5 Pro Review – A Powerful Phone Made For Gamers and Content Creators

      Scars Above Review – Sci-Fi Shooter Meets Souslike

      Scars Above Review – Sci-Fi Shooter Meets Souslike

      Atelier Ryza series anime adaptation

      Atelier Ryza Anime Adaptation Announced

      Hololive English To Have First Concert in LA

      Hololive English To Have First Concert in LA

      NVIDIA GeForce NOW Exclusive Beta Powered by Yes launched

      Yes 5G announces NVIDIA GeForce NOW Exclusive Beta for Malaysia Launched

      persona wada

      Persona Producer Kazuhisa Wada Talks About The Challenges Of Porting The Series To Modern Platforms

      SEGA Steam Spring Sale Announcement

      SEGA Steam Spring Sale offering up to 85% off

      Hunt The Night Release

      Hunt The Night Release Date Announced For PC Following Delay

    • Interviews
      resident evil knife

      Resident Evil 4 (2023) Interview: The New Knife Parry Was Made Specifically For The Krauser Fight

      World of Warcraft Embers of Neltharion

      Maria Hamilton And Patrick Dawson Promise Incredibly Slow Snail Mounts In Embers Of Neltharion

      Warwick PlayStation Malaysia

      Warwick Light Talks Getting More PlayStation 5 Units To Malaysians, Spider-Man In Bukit Bintang and His Love For Nasi Lemak

      final fantasy xvi ifrit

      Final Fantasy XVI Naoki Yoshida Interview: Ifrit Is The Main Eikon Because We Felt Sorry For Him

      Masahiro Inoue Interview – Getting to Know The Face of Kamen Rider Decade

      Masahiro Inoue Interview – Getting to Know The Face of Kamen Rider Decade

      Octopath Traveler interview

      Octopath Traveler II Interview: Producer Talks On Character Interaction and Further Evolving The HD-2D Art Style

      horizon interview

      Horizon Call Of The Mountain Interview: Narrative Director Ben McCaw On Adapting Horizon To VR

      Theatrhythm Interview

      Theatrhythm Final Bar Line Producer and Director Discuss Choosing Tracks From Each FF Game In New Interview

      WIld Hearts Interview

      Wild Hearts Directors Say They Want The Game To Be The Start of A “Saga”

      Trending Tags

      • CareerBraves
      • Media Partners
        • Wanuxi
        • Gamer Santai
        • GamerWK
      No Result
      View All Result
      GamerBraves
      No Result
      View All Result

      The Problem With The “It’s Too Anime” Argument For Xenoblade And Other Video Games

      It's almost like Japanese video games are influenced by Japanese culture

      Alex Daud Briggs by Alex Daud Briggs
      7 months ago
      in All, Anime, Console, Feature, News, Nintendo Switch (Platform), PS4 (Platform), PS5 (Platform), Steam, Windows, XBox One (Platform), XBox Series X (Platform)
      Reading Time: 5 mins read
      xenoblade too anime
      Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on TelegramShare on Whatsapp

      The article ‘The Problem With The “It’s Too Anime” Argument For Xenoblade And Other Video Games’ was available earlier through the Gamerbraves Newsletter. Sign up for free to gain access to more articles about news and trends in the gaming industry and community.

      Xenoblade Chronicles 3 has now graced the Switch with rave reviews. While many are excited to play the game, some players have one interesting concern on their minds: will it be “too anime”?

      Related Posts

      There Are More Elden Ring Deaths Than There Are People In The World

      Star Wars Jedi Survivor New Trailer Reunites with the Mantis Crew

      It’s a criticism that I’ve personally seen circulate through a lot of discussion about Japanese IPs like Fire Emblem, Shin Megami Tensei, Street Fighter, Tekken, Guilty Gear, and many others. Every time there’s a new entry into a classic Japanese franchise, it always seems to be “too anime” compared to the earlier titles.

      The argument has been heavily used against Xenoblade Chronicles 2 in comparison to the first Xenoblade due to it having things like more blatant fanservice, a more shounen hero, and a more “generic” art style and people are worried 3 might be the same. Is this complaint really valid though are Xenoblade and all these other games getting too anime?


      Follow @GamerBraves

      They’ve always been “anime”

      So what do people mean by too anime? It seems to be primarily the stereotypes most associated with anime, primarily. Shounen tropes like heroes screaming about friendship and dreams, fancy power-ups, and a lot of fanservice.

      People say that Xenoblade 2 was “too anime” and contained too many of these elements compared to Xenoblade 1, yet the first Xenoblade 1’s protagonist looks like this:

      Shulk over here looks unmistakably like a character out of an anime. In fact most of the plot points of Xenoblade 1: magic swords, giant sentient robots, and love triangles involving childhood friends have been staples of anime and JRPGs for years. If you want to go further, these were ideas that Xenoblade director Tetsuya Takahashi outright said were inspired by ‘Boys’ Manga’.

      Image Source: Twitter

      And if your problem is “too much fanservice” or “too many waifus”, well Xenoblade and even its predecessor Xenogears had those as well. Xenoblade Chronicles X even had a boob slider for its customizable characters and fans complained when it was removed from western versions of the game.

      If you look at other Japanese video game franchises, you’ll see that few of them stray from their anime roots: Shin Megami Tensei took elements from Devilman and even Dragon Ball Z, Guilty Gear is directly inspired by the manga Bastard and people complained about the new character Lucky Chloe in Tekken 7, yet Tekken has had anime-inspired characters since the original game.

      xenoblade too anime
      Hey King, Tiger Mask wants his gimmick back.

      At the end of the day, anime is a huge cultural institution in Japan, the same way Disney is in America. With that in mind, it makes sense that many Japanese video games take elements from anime. These are ideas that their Japanese staff and audience grew up with and are naturally familiar with. It would be pretty difficult to remove all that context when they likely consider these tropes and ideas fairly normal.

      What Counts as Too Anime?

      xenoblade too anime

      Another problem with the too anime criticism is that it’s hard to define what counts as anime. A lot of people treat the term “Anime” like it’s a genre, thinking only of the stereotypes from shows like Naruto and Demon Slayer.

      In reality, anime is a medium made up of multiple different genres and art styles. Cowboy Bebop is just as much an anime as Lucky Star, One Piece, or Panty and Stocking With Garterbelt. This further muddies the water of what “too anime” is supposed to mean as they are so many anime for video games to take ideas from making it difficult to figure out what aspect of anime people have a problem with.

      Dark Souls for example takes heavy inspiration from Berserk to the point that there are multiple Berserk references hidden in each of From Software’s games. Does this mean that the Souls games are also “too anime” since they clearly take inspiration from manga/anime? It’s almost like the term “anime” isn’t meant to be descriptive and becomes fairly meaningless when used as such.

      The Bad Aspects of Anime

      In all fairness, some people are a little more specific with the “too anime” argument. They may respond by saying that they don’t mind the game having anime elements but rather take issue with games implementing more tropes that they don’t like from anime to the point that they feel it’s a detriment to the series identity.

      xenoblade too anime

      For example, Dead or Alive has always been a pervy game with anime influences but it had a wide range of different ladies for different tastes. Dead or Alive 5 though, saw emphasis placed on new characters Marie Rose and Honoka: a gothic lolita, and a ditzy schoolgirl that’s basically a Love Live character, clearly meant to appeal to that stereotypical Otaku crowd. After that they quickly became the face of the series, being the mascots of Dead or Alive Xtreme 3 and were even the main character of Dead or Alive 6, overshadowing many of the prior characters and their more serious storylines.

      This argument is more understandable but is perhaps a little misplaced. If your problem with the game is that the writing or characters are bad then that’s all it is: the writing or characters. To me, it still feels disingenuous to say that the problem is it had anime influences when once again, that’s always been the case and it’s just that this time the execution wasn’t as good. For comparison, when a movie like Morbius or Fant4stic comes out, it’s not like people say that they’re “too comic book”.

      Once again, however, even if you try to say that “too anime” means “too many anime tropes”, a lot of those tropes still appear in older games. I mean, let’s not act like Kasumi, Ayane, and Hitomi from the earlier Dead or Alive games weren’t also meant to pander to anime-loving otaku.

      Closing Thoughts

      xenoblade too anime

      As previously stated, Japanese video games and anime are inherently interlinked. Without trying to strawman, a large chunk of the “too anime” crowd seems to come from westerners that find the Japanese influences too embarrassing for them to handle.

      There is nothing wrong with not liking anime, the problem comes with people saying that the anime is “ruining the series” when the term “anime” is so reductive. For example, I’ve even seen a video saying that fighting games would be able to break out into the mainstream if they were “less anime” but it never really explained what anime aspects the person wanted to be removed. Anime can mean so many different things that you can’t boil it down to a set of tropes you don’t like.

      I feel this argument also overlooks the fact that the anime influence on these games has always been an integral part of their inspiration and appeal. I honestly can’t imagine what a “less anime” Guilty Gear or even Street Fighter would look like and to be honest, I think they’d be pretty boring by comparison.

      Ultimately, the anime influences are likely here to stay and I think these franchises are probably better with them than without them. If one entry doesn’t quite get it right, let’s just hope they do better with the next one.


      Check This Out Next


      Tags: AnimeDead or AliveGuilty GearShin Megami TenseiTekkenXenoblade ChroniclesXenoblade Chronicles 3
      ShareTweetShareSend
      Previous Post

      Virtuos CEO Gilles Langourieux, Says Yes To Mobile Games, But No To NFTs For Now

      Next Post

      The International 11 tickets getting scalped on Carousell

      Alex Daud Briggs

      Alex Daud Briggs

      A gamer, movie buff and anime fan who enjoys seeking out obscure cult classics, and proceeding to find no one to to talk to about them. A big fan of JRPGs, Visuals Novels, and Nintendo games even if he has trouble affording them half of the time. Twitter: @Aleph_Daud.

      Related Posts

      Elden Ring Deaths
      News

      There Are More Elden Ring Deaths Than There Are People In The World

      March 21, 2023
      Star Wars Survivor Trailer
      News

      Star Wars Jedi Survivor New Trailer Reunites with the Mantis Crew

      March 21, 2023
      ROG Zephyrus M16
      Reviews

      ROG Zephyrus M16 (2023) Review – Flashy Aesthetics And High Performance Gaming

      March 21, 2023
      Next Post
      the international 11 tickets scalped

      The International 11 tickets getting scalped on Carousell

      Discussion about this post

      Follow us on Facebook

      Our Youtube Channel

      Our Twitter

      Tweets by GamerBraves

      GUIDE

      epic seven eligos

      [Guide] Epic Seven – Should You Pull For Eligos?

      by Alex Daud Briggs
      March 16, 2023
      0

      space donut

      [Guide] Cookie Run Kingdom – Should You Use Space Doughnut

      by Alex Daud Briggs
      March 13, 2023
      0

      genshin dehya

      [Guide] Genshin Impact – Dehya Kit and Build Overview

      by Alex Daud Briggs
      March 2, 2023
      0

      Nikke Makima

      [Guide] Nikke : Goddess of Victory – Should You Pull Makima

      by Lucas
      February 22, 2023
      0

      [Guide] Nikke: Goddess of Victory – Should You Pull Power

      [Guide] Nikke: Goddess of Victory – Should You Pull Power

      by Lucas
      February 21, 2023
      0

      • About GamerBraves
      • Contact Us
      • Privacy Policy

      © 2016 - 2022 Digital Braves Media Group Sdn Bhd

      No Result
      View All Result
      • News
      • Reviews
      • Interviews
      • CareerBraves
      • Media Partners
        • Wanuxi
        • Gamer Santai
        • GamerWK

      © 2016 - 2022 Digital Braves Media Group Sdn Bhd